For sale Detached

Shut Lane Head

Butterton, ST5 4DS

4 beds 3 baths Listed 26 Jul 2026 (-8d)

£1,450,000

Save

8694488-exterior01-800.jpg 8694488-exterior05-800.jpg 8694488-exterior08-800.jpg 8694488-exterior19-800.jpg 8694488-exterior20-800.jpg 8694488-exterior21-800.jpg 8694488-interior04-800.jpg 8694488-interior07-800.jpg 8694488-interior09-800.jpg 8694488-interior11-800.jpg 8694488-interior15-800.jpg 8694488-interior20-800.jpg 8694488-interior22-800.jpg 8694488-interior24-800.jpg 8694488-interior28-800.jpg 8694488-interior31-800.jpg 8694488-interior32-800.jpg 8694488-interior33-800.jpg 8694488-interior35-800.jpg 8694488-interior38-800.jpg 8694488-interior48-800.jpg 8694488-exterior06-800.jpg

/ 22

Property details

Tenure

FREEHOLD

Council tax band

D

Local average

£338,414 (+328.5%)

Deprivation

Decile 8 (24,560 of 33,755)

Street crime

3 incidents within 1 mile (May 2026)

Key features

  • Luxurious family home
  • Prime North Staffordshire location
  • 400-year-old Period house
  • Extended in 2014
  • Detached house, 5,800 sq ft
  • 4 spacious bedrooms
  • 3 modern bathrooms
  • 5 elegant reception rooms
  • Exclusive residential area

Additional details

Electricity
Mains supply
Broadband
FTTP (fibre to the premises)
Water
Mains supply
Sewerage
Private supply
Heating
Oil, Open fire, Underfloor heating
Accessibility
Wet room
Parking
Garage, Driveway, EV charging, Private
Garden
Yes
Listed property
No
Restrictions
No
Required access
No
Rights of way
No
Flooded in last 5 years
No
Flood defences
No

Description

Nestled in the prestigious area of Shut Lane Head, Butterton, this exquisite period detached house offers a remarkable blend of historical charm and modern luxury. Spanning an impressive 5,800 square feet, this spacious family home is perfect for those seeking both comfort and elegance.

The property boasts five generously sized reception rooms, providing ample space for entertaining guests or enjoying quiet family time. With four well-appointed bedrooms, there is plenty of room for family members or visitors, ensuring everyone has their own private sanctuary. The three bathrooms are thoughtfully designed, catering to the needs of a busy household while maintaining a sense of style and sophistication.

Originally built around 400 years ago, this home has undergone significant modernisation and renovation, with a major update completed in 1996 and a tasteful extension added in 2014. This careful blend of old and new creates a unique atmosphere, where period features harmoniously coexist with contemporary conveniences.

Set in one of North Staffordshire's most exclusive residential areas, this luxurious property is not only a home but a lifestyle choice. The surrounding landscape offers a tranquil setting, perfect for those who appreciate the beauty of nature while still being within easy reach of local amenities and transport links.

In summary, this stunning detached house on Shut Lane Head is a rare opportunity to acquire a luxurious family home in a sought-after location. With its spacious layout, modern amenities, and rich history, it is sure to impress even the most discerning buyers.

Accommodation -

Downstairs - Canopy porch leads into a welcoming dining hall, where original oak beams, a warm wooden floor, and a chimney breast with open fire set the tone for the home’s character and comfort. From here, a panelled inner hall with turned staircase rises to the first-floor gallery landing, and discreetly tucked away is the downstairs cloakroom. The sitting room is brimming with character, featuring a beamed ceiling and original exposed timber frame that naturally creates a cosy snug area. With a dual aspect overlooking the gardens, a chimney breast with wood-burning stove, French doors to the front, and double doors flowing into the garden room and kitchen, it’s a space as practical as it is inviting. The open-plan kitchen, added in 2014, is the heart of the home – a fabulous space for living, dining, and entertaining. It boasts a bespoke hand-painted design with an Aga range, a large island with breakfast bar, and bi-fold windows that open to the garden for a true inside-outside feel. Practicality is just as well considered, with a boot room and utility room directly off the kitchen, and a quiet study off the entrance hall that leads through to the garage and the staircase to the gym.

Upstairs - The gallery landing is a striking feature in itself, with a tall vaulted ceiling, exposed beams, and an original timber frame lending warmth and character. The main bedroom is a true retreat – enjoying a triple aspect with garden views and west-facing vistas across the beautiful Staffordshire countryside. It includes an adjoining dressing area and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. The guest bedroom offers its own touch of indulgence, with a walk-through dressing area leading to a full en-suite bathroom. Two further double bedrooms provide generous family or guest accommodation, served by a stylish family shower room.

Gym - The gym is part of, yet distinct from, the main house – accessed via a hidden staircase from the study. This versatile room is suited to a wide range of uses, whether as a dedicated fitness space, studio, or hobby room. It features a tall vaulted ceiling with six skylight windows, an oak floor, and installation for a wall-mounted TV. A cloakroom with WC adds further convenience.

Outside & Gardens - Oak House is discreetly positioned at the end of a quiet lane, backing onto open farmland along the rear boundary. A long gravel driveway, accessed via remotely operated wooden gates, provides an elegant approach to the property. There is generous parking for several vehicles, along with a large two-car garage and a substantial brick-built store to the rear of the house. The gardens wrap around three sides of the property, ensuring sunshine throughout the day. They are mainly laid to lawn and bordered by tall hedges for seclusion, with extensive planted borders adding colour and interest. Several paved patio areas offer perfect spots for outdoor dining and relaxation. The property does have a couple of nearby neighbours but the gardens enjoy complete privacy. There is also a well in the garden

The Area - Shut Lane Head is an exclusive residential location about 2 miles to the west of Newcastle-under-Lyme with countryside walks on the doorstep.

Minutes away from the Royal Stoke Hospital complex and Keele University and within easy reach of the A34, A500 and M6, the property is within easy commuting distance of The Potteries, Stone and Stafford and 10 mins from the Royal Stoke Hospital complex. Stoke-on-Trent station is nearby: London Euston 1hr 40 mins, Manchester Piccadilly 45 mins, Birmingham New Street 40 mins. Manchester, Liverpool, Birmingham and East Midlands airports are all within a hour's drive.

General Information - Services; Mains electricity & water. Drainage to a septic tank. Oil fired central heating. Wood burning Stove.

Tenure; Freehold

Council Tax Band D

what3words location; edges.spare.yappy

Viewing by appointment

Freehold Asking price £1,450,000

For sale by private treaty, subject to contract.
Vacant possession on completion

Listed by

Stone

Tinsley-Garner Independent Estate Agents

Reference: 91330431

EPC ratings on this postcode

We don't have a matched EPC for this property yet. Below are efficiency scores and details for other addresses on this postcode.

Address Current Potential Floor area Age band Type
Brackenwood, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 25 65 201 m² England and Wales: 1950-1966 House
Brackenwood, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 25 65 201 m² England and Wales: 1950-1966 Detached
Brick Kiln House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 49 55 513 m² England and Wales: 1930-1949 House
Brick Kiln House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 49 55 513 m² Detached
Hilltop, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 44 69 208 m² England and Wales: before 1900 House
Hilltop, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 44 69 208 m² England and Wales: before 1900 Detached
Oak House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 61 71 450 m² England and Wales: 1900-1929 House
Oak House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 61 71 450 m² England and Wales: 1900-1929 Detached
The Grange, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 42 51 344 m² England and Wales: 1930-1949 House
The Grange, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 42 51 344 m² England and Wales: 1930-1949 Detached
The Old Dairy House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 70 87 222 m² House
The Old Dairy House, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 70 87 222 m² Detached
Upper Farm, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 71 77 321 m² England and Wales: 2003-2006 House
Upper Farm, Shut Lane Head, Butterton 58 64 362 m² England and Wales: 1996-2002 House
Upper Farm, Shut Lane Head, Butterton, NEWCASTLE 72 74 313 m² England and Wales: 1900-1929 Detached

Flood risk

Zone: 1

Risk: Low

Job (default Low)

Floorplans

Oak House

Oak House

Ground Floor

Ground Floor

First Floor

First Floor

First Floor Gym

First Floor Gym

EPC Graphs

EE Rating

EE Rating

EI Rating

EI Rating

Price history

Event Date Price % change
Listed for sale £1,450,000

Source: HM Land Registry Price Paid Data. Crown copyright.

Sold Comparables

Same street and nearby sales within 0.25 miles (last 5 years). Data from Land Registry Price Paid.

Address Price Date Type
Same street HILLTOP SHUT LANE HEAD, BUTTERTON, NEWCASTLE, NEWCASTLE-UNDER-LYME, STAFFORDSHIRE, ST5 4DS £711,000 01/12/2025 Detached

Street average: £711,000 (1 sale)

Capital growth trend

Land Registry outcode average: last 12 months vs 5y and 10y ago (from sold prices).

5y growth 26.4%
10y growth 28.7%

House Price Index (HM Land Registry — official index, not sold-price averages): Newcastle-under-Lyme. Series: Detached. As of April 2026.

1y (index) 1%
5y (index) 26.1%
10y (index) 54.9%

Rental Range

Estimated market rent for Newcastle-under-Lyme. Low = conservative, Realistic = average, Optimistic = best case.

Low £744/mo
Realistic £827/mo
Optimistic £910/mo

Based on Local Authority from postcode lookup → Newcastle-under-Lyme.

LHA (30th percentile) floor for Staffordshire North: £798/mo (Apr 2025 – Mar 2026)

Location

Address

Shut Lane Head

Nearby

Nearest stations, universities and amenities (distance from property).

Type Name Distance
Bus stop Shutlanehead 0.1 miles
Shop WHSmith 1.5 miles
Shop Waitrose 1.5 miles
University Keele University 1.6 miles
Train station Trentham Leisure 3.0 miles
Train station Unknown 3.2 miles
Hospital Haywood Hospital Walk-in Centre 6.3 miles
University University of Buckingham Crewe Campus 10.3 miles
Hospital Cheadle Hosptal 11.5 miles

Street-level crime

Category Count
Violence and sexual offences 2
Public order 1
Total incidents 3

Within 1 mile during May 2026. Source: data.police.uk (England & Wales).

Schools nearby

Nearest open schools with Ofsted ratings (England). Closed schools are not shown. Data from Get Information about Schools and Ofsted.

Name Type Distance Ofsted
Seabridge Primary School Primary 1.6 miles Good — 22 Mar 2012
Our Lady and St Werburgh's Catholic Primary School Primary 1.8 miles Good — 11 Apr 2014
University of Keele Other 1.9 miles (No rating)
Langdale Primary School Primary 1.9 miles Good — 15 Sep 2024
Westlands Primary School Primary 1.9 miles Good — 27 Nov 2023

Rental Comparables

Residential lets from OpenRent and Rightmove for the area (same bedroom count). Use to validate rent estimates. Student lets are excluded.

Title Rent Beds Distance As seen on
The Coach House, Butterton, ST5 £3,000/mo 4 0.4 miles Rightmove
The Coach House, Butterton, Newcastle Under Lyme, Staffordshire, ST5 £4,995/mo 4 0.41 miles Rightmove
Newcastle Road, Whitmore, Newcastle, Staffordshire, ST5 £2,700/mo 1.65 miles Rightmove
Whitmore Heath, Newcastle, Staffordshire, ST5 £1,800/mo 4 1.71 miles Rightmove
Essex Place, The Westlands, Newcastle-Under-Lyme, Staffordshire, ST5 £1,995/mo 4 1.93 miles Rightmove
Beresford Crescent, Newcastle-Under-Lyme, ST5 £3,950/mo 4 2.07 miles Rightmove
Snowgoose Way, Newcastle £1,600/mo 4 2.44 miles Rightmove
Sutton Avenue, Newcastle-Under-Lyme, ST5 £1,700/mo 4 2.76 miles Rightmove
First Floor Flat, 65 High Street, Newcastle, ST5 1PN £725/mo 2.81 miles Rightmove
Vickers Close, Newcastle Under Lyme, ST5 £1,550/mo 4 3.13 miles Rightmove
Car Park Lymedale Cross Industrial Estate, Newcastle Under Lyme ST5 £1/mo 3.49 miles Rightmove

Average rent: £2,183/mo (11 listings)

Rent-driven metrics

Based on OpenRent comparables.

Rent ratio 0.12%
Max investor price (0.8%) £225,000
Target investor price (1%) £180,000
Gross yield 1.5%
Cost-to-rent ratio 67.1×
Monthly cashflow £-4,115/mo 75% LTV, 3.95% APR (5yr fixed), 25yr term
Cash-on-cash ROI -11.7%
  • Rent ratio — Monthly rent ÷ purchase price (1% rule). 1%+ = strong, 0.8–1% = okay, <0.8% = weak for cashflow.
  • Max investor price — Rent ÷ 0.8%; the price at which rent would be 0.8% of price (Stoke-style target).
  • Target investor price — Rent ÷ 1%; the price at which rent would be 1% of price (strong cashflow band).
  • Gross yield — Annual rent as % of purchase price (no costs).
  • Cost-to-rent — Price ÷ annual rent (from OpenRent comparables). Under 14× = strong, 14–16× = acceptable, 17×+ = compressed.
  • Cashflow — Rent minus mortgage, 10% maintenance, £25/mo compliance. Assumes 75% LTV, 3.95% APR (5yr fixed), 25yr term.
  • ROI — Annual profit ÷ cash in (deposit + 4% purchase costs).

Enter House Number

Enter the house number to help us retrieve more accurate pricing history and property data.

Please log in to submit or correct the house number for this listing.

Log in to continue